Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
9 changes: 0 additions & 9 deletions assets/css/doors/article.css
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -635,15 +635,6 @@ html:has(.list-filter-section){scroll-padding-top:calc(var(--list-filter-bar,0px
.article-layout .article-card .toc-cite{display:none}
/* Below 1000 px the card follows the text and leaves its contents out, so the citation needs no rule above it. */
@media(max-width:1000px){.article-layout .card-cite{margin-top:0;padding-top:0;border-top:0}}
/* A team's plans, as on Citational Justice: running text on the area's pale ground, in two balanced columns where
they fit, so six lists read as one set rather than a long column. */
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board{columns:2 260px;column-gap:36px;margin:24px 0 28px;padding:24px 28px 8px;background:var(--jus-bg);border-radius:var(--r-large)}
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board>div{break-inside:avoid;padding-bottom:4px}
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board h3{margin:0 0 8px;font-size:21px;line-height:1.2}
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board ul{margin:0 0 18px;padding-inline-start:1.1em}
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board ul ul{margin:6px 0 0}
.article-layout .article-style .plan-board li{font-size:17px;line-height:1.45;margin-bottom:6px}
@media(max-width:760px){.article-layout .article-style .plan-board{padding:18px 18px 4px}}
@media(max-width:1000px){
.article-layout .card-authors>li>div>.network-icon{margin-inline-start:-13px}
.article-layout .card-authors .network-icon a{width:44px;height:44px}
Expand Down
17 changes: 6 additions & 11 deletions assets/css/doors/sections.css
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -324,16 +324,14 @@ html:has(.contributor-az){scroll-padding-top:calc(var(--contributor-az,72px) + 1
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-result a{display:inline-flex;align-items:center;min-height:44px;color:var(--link);font-weight:600}
.contributor-result+#contributor-list .contributor-letter-heading,.contributor-result+.contributor-az+#contributor-list .contributor-letter-heading{margin-top:16px}
/* Filtered to one project, a row gives only the person's roles in it, as the heading names the project (the script
hides the project's name, link and all); the rows are then short, so a wide screen takes three columns of them. */
hides the project's name, link and all). */
.article-layout .article-style #contributor-list.is-project-filtered .contribution{max-width:30em;margin:0;padding:0;text-indent:0;font-size:16px;line-height:1.45}
.article-layout .article-style #contributor-list.is-project-filtered .contribution>[hidden]{display:none}
#contributor-list.is-project-filtered .contribution-roles{display:inline}
#contributor-list.is-project-filtered .contribution-roles::before{content:none}
@media(min-width:1100px){.article-layout .article-style #contributor-list.is-project-filtered ul.contributor-rows{columns:3;column-gap:40px}}
/* Each letter: its heading, then one row per person, the name on the left and the projects, each with its roles
after it, on the right, with a hairline between people. Contributions are very unequal, so a heavy contributor
makes a taller row and leaves no gap beside it (DESIGN.md §4). On a wide screen the rows run in two columns, the
name above its projects (below); on a phone the name sits above too. */
makes a taller row and leaves no gap beside it (DESIGN.md §4). On a phone the name sits above its projects. */
.contributor-letter{margin:0 0 28px}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-letter-heading{margin:28px 0 0;padding:0 0 6px;font:500 36px/1 var(--display);color:var(--ink);border-bottom:2px solid var(--ink)}
.article-layout .article-style ul.contributor-rows{max-width:none;margin:0;padding:0;list-style:none}
Expand All @@ -347,13 +345,10 @@ html:has(.contributor-az){scroll-padding-top:calc(var(--contributor-az,72px) + 1
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contributions-list{max-width:none;margin:0;padding:0;list-style:none}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contribution{max-width:27em;margin:0 0 4px;font-size:17px;line-height:1.45}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contribution:last-child{margin-bottom:0}
/* On a wide screen the people of a letter run in two columns, down the first and on in the second, as in an index;
each name stands over its projects, so most rows fill their column instead of leaving the right half empty. */
@media(min-width:1100px){
.article-layout .article-style ul.contributor-rows{columns:2;column-gap:56px}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows>.contributor-group{display:block;break-inside:avoid}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contributor-name{margin:0 0 4px}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contribution{max-width:28em}
/* On a wide screen a long list of projects runs in two columns, so the row uses the width beside the name. */
@media(min-width:1200px){
.article-layout .article-style #contributor-list:not(.is-project-filtered) .contributor-rows .contributions-list{columns:2;column-gap:32px}
.article-layout .article-style .contributor-rows .contribution{break-inside:avoid}
}
.contribution-roles{color:var(--soft);font-size:16px}
/* Project links in the rows have a quieter underline than the names, at full strength under the pointer or focus, so
Expand Down
35 changes: 0 additions & 35 deletions content/citation-politics/_index.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -25,10 +25,6 @@ The Citational Justice Toolkit organizes a collection of tools and practices by

The aim of this toolkit is to encourage individual researchers to become conscientious in their citation practices, using their citation choices to distribute power more equitably in the academy. We invite you to explore the Citational Justice Toolkit and join us in promoting equity and justice in academia.





# Toolkit

---
Expand All @@ -43,13 +39,11 @@ We provide a suite of resources to support the use and implementation of the Cit
Decades of empirical research across disciplines reveal the pervasiveness of citation biases along axes of gender, race, geography, and epistemology. Who we cite reflects and reinforces both the boundaries and hierarchies of academic knowledge, covertly shaping not only whose research is legitimized and valued but also whose careers are advanced. Citations, the currency of the academy with power to reinforce or dismantle hierarchies that privilege dominant knowledge systems cannot thus be a neutral, apolitical act. This paper unpacks the concept of ***citation politics*** and its role in sustaining epistemic hierarchies within scholarly communities. Rather than framing citation bias as a matter of individual oversight, we position it as a systemic issue tied to academic structures, norms, and incentive systems. We introduce a comprehensive and openly accessible Citational Justice Toolkit, developed by the FORRT community, which curates actionable resources, tools, and practices helping scholars and institutions to audit, diversify, and reflect on their citation practices across the research cycle. Our aim is to support a shift from tokenistic inclusion toward epistemically accountable, socially responsible, and structurally aware scholarship. We argue that reimagining citation as an ethical and epistemic practice is foundational to building a just and inclusive academic ecosystem, fostering pluralism, transparency, and integrity in knowledge production.
{{< /expand >}}


### Video guide
You’ve read our manuscript and now you’re wondering how to get started? This video will walk you through the first steps you can take on your journey towards citational justice, featuring several tools and practices from our toolkit.

{{< youtube HuQEmrME6uk >}}


# Coming Up

---
Expand All @@ -70,21 +64,12 @@ This workshop will guide you through applying the Citational Justice Toolkit to
This toolkit and accompanying manuscript are only the first piece of work produced by FORRT’s Team Citation Politics.
For **FORRT’s Team Citation Politics** [(#citation-politics)](https://forrt.slack.com/archives/C074E9LDES2), we devised a few action points we will be working on:

<!-- The team's plans on the area's pale ground, two to a row on wide screens (assets/css/doors/article.css). -->
<div class="plan-board">

<div>

### Toolkit Expansion and Infrastructure Building
- Modularize the toolkit by audience: for authors, editors, instructors, students.
- Create an interactive online dashboard to visualize citation audits
- Add discipline-specific add-ons (e.g., citational politics in psychology vs. physics vs. education).
- Translate into multiple languages (for inclusivity and global engagement).

</div>

<div>

### Empirical Research Agenda
- Launch a study or dashboard documenting uptake of the toolkit.
- Conduct longitudinal citation audits by field or journal using gender, region, epistemology as categories.
Expand All @@ -93,46 +78,26 @@ For **FORRT’s Team Citation Politics** [(#citation-politics)](https://forrt.sl
- Integrate and expand categories with those of the Academic Wheel of Privilege.
- Study via Dimensions & Altmetric data to see whether citations across papers with low and high diversity rank higher or lower on Dimensions & Altmetric areas.

</div>

<div>

### Pedagogical Integration
- Develop lesson plans or mini-courses on citational justice for undergrad and graduate levels.
- Offer “Citation Justice Audits” as a classroom or lab-based activity.
- Build partnerships with educational institutions, writing centers, and PhD programs to mainstream ethical citation training.

</div>

<div>

### Institutional Policy Engagement
- Collaborate with academic publishers, funding agencies, and research offices to:
- Add citational ethics criteria in journal editorial guidelines.
- Include citation audits in grant application protocols or DEIA reviews.
- Propose policy changes within hiring, tenure, and promotion frameworks.

</div>

<div>

### Coalition-Building
- Form a FORRT-led network of citation justice advocates.
- Organize a citational justice conference or symposium with panels on data ethics, metrics reform, and DEI in publishing.
- Partner with initiatives like DORA, CRediT, AfricArXiv, or PREreview to co-develop standards.

</div>

<div>

### Critical Discourse Amplification

- Publish a shorter companion piece for Nature Human Behaviour or The Conversation to distill key points.
- Use social media and public writing to popularize the metaphor of citation as epistemic infrastructure.
- Share testimonies of those excluded from citations (e.g., oral histories, blog interviews).

</div>

</div>

If you see yourself in any of these plans or have any other ideas or suggestions for development of the toolkit, or other ways of engaging with citational practice or patterns (especially as it relates to open research), get in touch via the [#citation-politics channel on FORRT’s Slack](https://forrt.slack.com/archives/C074E9LDES2), email the team at citation-politics@forrt.org, or DM either Team Co-Lead **Sarah Sauvé** or **Helena Gellersen** on [FORRT’s Slack](https://join.slack.com/t/forrt/shared_invite/enQtODMwODI0OTk4ODgzLTM0ZTQ3NDk5MzA1ZjBmNWJjYTVlN2Y2YTk0ZTJhYTY5NDliMDYzMjg2MWE0ZDRhOTY0ZDY3OTRlNDA4ODQ3NjQ).
Loading