diff --git a/data/specifications/netex.md b/data/specifications/netex.md index cb3e012..e41d9f8 100644 --- a/data/specifications/netex.md +++ b/data/specifications/netex.md @@ -15,24 +15,24 @@ adoption: tier: early principles: cost_restriction_free: - verdict: compliant - rationale: GPL 3.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/NeTEx-CEN/NeTEx/blob/v2.0/LICENSE + verdict: not_compliant + rationale: The normative specification (CEN/TS 16614) must be purchased from national standardization bodies. + evidence_url: https://www.sis.se/en/produkter/information-technology-office-machines/applications-of-information-technology/it-applications-in-transport/sis-cents-16614-12020/ publicly_documented: verdict: partially_compliant - rationale: Unable to find full public documentation. - evidence_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/netex/ + rationale: The XML schemas are freely available under GPL 3.0, but the full normative documentation must be purchased. + evidence_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/netex independent_maintainer: - verdict: not_compliant - rationale: Governmental institution - evidence_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/legal-context/ + verdict: compliant + rationale: CEN is a non-profit association whose standards are approved through formal votes by national standardization bodies, so that no single company, funder, or commercial group controls their content. Working groups are held with industry experts and project teams funded by the European Commission, but final decisions rest with CEN process. + evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/about-cen/structure-and-governance/cen-board-members structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Versioning + rationale: Versioning available evidence_url: http://github.com/NeTEx-CEN/NeTEx/releases open_governance: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: One vote per EU and some neighbouring countries. - Working Group participation requirements are unclear, potentail for industry conflict. + rationale: NeTEx and SIRI are developed within CEN/TC 278/WG 3, where direct participation in meetings and decisions requires nomination through a national standardization body, which can involve membership fees. Working documents are not publicly accessible, and final approval is reserved to formal votes by national members. evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/european-standardization/cen-and-cenelec/ --- diff --git a/data/specifications/ojp.md b/data/specifications/ojp.md index 484204c..5baba44 100644 --- a/data/specifications/ojp.md +++ b/data/specifications/ojp.md @@ -1,38 +1,35 @@ --- short_name: OJP -full_name: Open Journey Planner +full_name: Open API for distributed Journey Planning homepage_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/ojp/ status: not_compliant modes: [public_transport] maintainers: [cen] -licences: -- id: Proprietary -- id: Apache-2.0 - scopes: [specification] +licences: [] first_release_year: 2017 adoption: lifecycle: active tier: pilot principles: cost_restriction_free: - verdict: unknown - rationale: No licence specified - evidence_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/ojp/ + verdict: not_compliant + rationale: The normative specification (CEN/TS 17118) must be purchased from national standardization bodies. + evidence_url: https://www.dinmedia.de/en/pre-standard/din-cen-ts-17118/375690154 publicly_documented: verdict: partially_compliant - rationale: Only the technical XML schema and API endpoints are published. - evidence_url: https://github.com/VDVde/OJP + rationale: The XML schemas, examples and generated documentation tables are publicly available on GitHub, but the full normative documentation must be purchased. + evidence_url: https://vdvde.github.io/OJP/index.html independent_maintainer: - verdict: partially_compliant - rationale: Governmental institution - evidence_url: https://www.itsstandards.eu/ + verdict: compliant + rationale: CEN is a non-profit association whose standards are approved through formal votes by national standardization bodies, so that no single company, funder, or commercial group controls their content. Working groups are held with industry experts and project teams funded by the European Commission, but final decisions rest with CEN process. The XML schema repository is hosted by VDV, the German association of transport companies. + evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/about-cen/structure-and-governance/cen-board-members structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Yes, major releases (OJP 1.0, 2.0) are published via CEN and GitHub. - evidence_url: https://github.com/VDVde/OJP/blob/develop/CHANGELOG.md + rationale: Versioned releases (OJP 1.0, 1.0.1 and 2.0) matching the CEN documentation are published on GitHub. + evidence_url: https://github.com/VDVde/OJP/releases open_governance: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: Unclear, no information on adoped changes after a pull request. + rationale: OJP is developed within CEN/TC 278/WG 3, where direct participation in meetings and decisions requires nomination through a national standardization body, which can involve membership fees. Working documents are not publicly accessible, and final approval is reserved to formal votes by national members. Contributions to the XML schemas are possible on GitHub, but the process for adopting them is not documented. evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/european-standardization/cen-and-cenelec/ --- diff --git a/data/specifications/opra.md b/data/specifications/opra.md index 9ca9620..b8c79b1 100644 --- a/data/specifications/opra.md +++ b/data/specifications/opra.md @@ -1,42 +1,41 @@ --- short_name: OpRa -full_name: Operational Raw Data -homepage_url: http://transmodel-cen.eu/opra +full_name: Operating Raw Data and Statistics Exchange +homepage_url: https://www.opra-cen.eu/ status: not_compliant modes: [public_transport] maintainers: [cen] licences: - id: GPL-3.0 scopes: [specification] -first_release_year: 2018 +first_release_year: 2026 adoption: lifecycle: pre_adoption tier: none confirmed_by_maintainer: false principles: cost_restriction_free: - verdict: compliant - rationale: GPL 3.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/OpRa-CEN/OpRa/blob/1.0rc/LICENSE - publicly_documented: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: Unable to find full public documentation. - independent_maintainer: + rationale: The XML schemas are available under GPL 3.0, but the normative specification (CEN/TS 17370) must be purchased. + evidence_url: https://genorma.com/en/standards/cen-ts-17370-2026 + publicly_documented: verdict: partially_compliant - rationale: |- - CEN - - Working Group participation requirements are unclear, potentail for industry conflict. + rationale: The XML schemas are freely available under GPL 3.0, but the full normative documentation must be purchased. + evidence_url: https://github.com/OpRa-CEN/OpRa + independent_maintainer: + verdict: compliant + rationale: CEN is a non-profit association whose standards are approved through formal votes by national standardization bodies, so that no single company, funder, or commercial group controls their content. Working groups are held with industry experts and project teams funded by the European Commission, but final decisions rest with CEN process. + evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/about-cen/structure-and-governance/cen-board-members structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Versioning is planned. - evidence_url: https://github.com/OpRa-CEN/OpRa/releases + rationale: Version 1.0 of the XML schemas, matching CEN/TS 17370:2026, is published on GitHub. + evidence_url: https://github.com/OpRa-CEN/OpRa open_governance: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: One vote per EU and some neighbouring countries. + rationale: OpRa is developed within CEN/TC 278/WG 3, where direct participation in meetings and decisions requires nomination through a national standardization body, which can involve membership fees. Working documents are not publicly accessible, and final approval is reserved to formal votes by national members. evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/european-standardization/cen-and-cenelec/ --- # Description -Archive of observed data about transit operations for future planning +Exchange of historical public transport operations data, such as observed run times, delays, cancellations and passenger loads, for planning and service analysis. diff --git a/data/specifications/siri.md b/data/specifications/siri.md index b623e87..c228e29 100644 --- a/data/specifications/siri.md +++ b/data/specifications/siri.md @@ -1,43 +1,37 @@ --- short_name: SIRI -full_name: Service Interface for Real Time Information -homepage_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/siri/ +full_name: Service Interface for Real-time Information +homepage_url: https://github.com/TransmodelEcosystem/SIRI status: not_compliant modes: [public_transport] maintainers: [cen] -licences: -- id: Crown-Copyright - scopes: [specification] +licences: [] first_release_year: 2006 adoption: lifecycle: active - tier: hundred_plus - confirmed_by_maintainer: true + tier: early principles: cost_restriction_free: - verdict: unknown - rationale: No licence specified - evidence_url: https://github.com/TransmodelEcosystem/SIRI - publicly_documented: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: Schemas available, no full and clear documentation available. - evidence_url: https://transmodel-cen.eu/index.php/uml-documents/ - independent_maintainer: + rationale: The normative specification (EN 15531 and CEN/TS 15531) must be purchased from national standardization bodies. + evidence_url: https://www.austrian-standards.at/de/shop/onorm-en-15531-1-2022-10-01~p2637091 + publicly_documented: verdict: partially_compliant - rationale: |- - CEN - Working Group participation requirements are unclear - - Governmental entity (EU) + rationale: The XML schemas and examples are publicly available on GitHub, but the full normative documentation must be purchased. + evidence_url: https://github.com/TransmodelEcosystem/SIRI + independent_maintainer: + verdict: compliant + rationale: CEN is a non-profit association whose standards are approved through formal votes by national standardization bodies, so that no single company, funder, or commercial group controls their content. Working groups are held with industry experts and project teams funded by the European Commission, but final decisions rest with CEN process. + evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/about-cen/structure-and-governance/cen-board-members structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Versioning - evidence_url: https://github.com/SIRI-CEN/SIRI/releases + rationale: Versioned releases matching the CEN documentation are published on GitHub. + evidence_url: https://github.com/TransmodelEcosystem/SIRI/releases open_governance: verdict: not_compliant - rationale: Unclear, no information on adoped changes after a pull request. + rationale: SIRI is developed within CEN/TC 278/WG 3, where direct participation in meetings and decisions requires nomination through a national standardization body, which can involve membership fees. Working documents are not publicly accessible, and final approval is reserved to formal votes by national members. evidence_url: https://www.cencenelec.eu/european-standardization/cen-and-cenelec/ --- - # Description -Exchange of realtime information about schedules, vehicles, transfers, and additional informational messages about operational status +Exchange of real-time public transport information, including vehicle positions, estimated timetables, stop monitoring, and service disruptions.